Was there a goal missed yesterday? (game 2)

[Rick Zombos Ghost 82]

I caught it on my DVR while watching the game. There was a wrap around where Niemmi stopped a stuff in with his pad waaaaaay behind the goal line.

NBC quickly went to commercial and never mentioned it again or showed a replay. I thought i was the one crazy person who was seeing things but calls have been going into 97.1 about it.....

[HankthaTank 1,100]

Hmm, yeah the play seemed a bit odd. The Franzen one right?? Seemed to be quite tough to make that stop the way he did. I hope we aren't grasping here but as we know, any goals would have helped the ice tilt.

[ACallToArms 270]

Video? I haven't heard about this.

[GMRwings1983 8,794]

I'd love to see a replay.

Are you talking about the play where Franzen seemed to miss the wraparound?

[Carman 387]

At 9:38

[Rick Zombos Ghost 82]

I'd love to see a replay.

Are you talking about the play where Franzen seemed to miss the wraparound?

yep. someone on 97.1 said they saw a replay where it is in the net.

I cant believe that the redwings video review guys would have missed that during the commercial break....

[wingnut40 176]

Uhhh did Niemi kick it out of the net there?!

Edited May 2, 2011 by wingnut40

[GMRwings1983 8,794]

At 9:38

That was the game feed, though.

Did they show an in depth replay during the game? I don't seem to think so.

[Firehawk 305]

Why am i not surprised? I thought toronto was always reviewing every play...hmm.

[b.shanafan14 733]

I was wondering why they didn't review that either, I know it didn't look definitively out, though I don't see it in either.

The thing that pissed me off the most about that play was not two minutes before Holmstrom got the only penalty in a scrum after getting swatted at by two Sharks, one from behind. Then this play happens and the refs are watching Mitchell throw a headlock on Eaves, continue to twist him awkwardly on the ice and not let go for a good minute with no call while the linesman just sits there like 'come on, please?'. That more than anything got my blood boiling.

[Mitchmac33 103]

That was the game feed, though.

Did they show an in depth replay during the game? I don't seem to think so.

I think they did show a replay from the net camera, because i remember thinking "how did he not score" and i watched for the puck but couldn't see it.

[Rick Zombos Ghost 82]

if this game was done by FS-D ill bet their producers would have been going right to the off ice official.....

[hillbillywingsfan 792]

go to exactly 9:40. puck is in the net. he then kicks it out. watch it

[Rick Zombos Ghost 82]

go to exactly 9:40. puck is in the net. he then kicks it out. watch it

id like to see an actual news article on this. the NBC coverage is beyond awful. to have a start time of 3:00pm yet they dont drop the puck for 20 minutes so they can repeat the same "analysis" over and over. any borderline hockey fan is going to be beyond bored and flip it off. one 5 min segment setting up the game would be fine.

[HankthaTank 1,100]

Puck under pad

pad crosses goal line

puck can't be seen

We all know how this would have gone if they did review it... More outrage, still would have been nice to have given it a look.

Still need to play better regardless of this crap.

[hillbillywingsfan 792]

Puck under pad

pad crosses goal line

puck can't be seen

We all know how this would have gone if they did review it... More outrage, still would have been nice to have given it a look.

Still need to play better regardless of this crap.

no per that video that was posted and the time i posted the puck is across the line. you can see it. start at 9:40..then slowly move it up. it wasn't under his pad at all

[esteef 2,679]

Hard to see but maybe he made the initial save then was push in when Franzen went down. Certainly should've been reviewed though.

esteef

[jollymania 162]

you can clearly tell it is in

[hillbillywingsfan 792]

Hard to see but maybe he made the initial save then was push in when Franzen went down. Certainly should've been reviewed though.

esteef

im leaning towards that. that was probably the reason but they could have at least looked at it.

[esteef 2,679]

im leaning towards that. that was probably the reason but they could have at least looked at it.

Yep, the whistle comes right after Franzen goes down (and pushes Niemi in the net) which means the ref probably wanted to blow it before that (see intent to blow rule). Could also explain why they didn't even look at it. Either that or there's a conspiracy and the refs are in on it!

esteef

[hillbillywingsfan 792]

Yep, the whistle comes right after Franzen goes down (and pushes Niemi in the net) which means the ref probably wanted to blow it before that (see intent to blow rule). Could also explain why they didn't even look at it. Either that or there's a conspiracy and the refs are in on it!

esteef

oh geez. you had to go and say the C word.=)

[Rick Zombos Ghost 82]

Yep, the whistle comes right after Franzen goes down (and pushes Niemi in the net) which means the ref probably wanted to blow it before that (see intent to blow rule). Could also explain why they didn't even look at it. Either that or there's a conspiracy and the refs are in on it!

esteef

Niemi went in under his own steam. He was playing deep in the net.

If there was intent to blow the whistle there shouldnt have been because the puck was WAY loose. Either way id expect to at least here something about it from the wings so they could sway some calls on wednesday.

[Wing Across The Pond 196]

Have to admit, watched the game on TSN last night, showed extensive replays including the overhead. Puck never went in. Never even went near the post so that isn't a puck at 9:40. What happened was he tried wrapping it around too soon, and instead of getting it into the post, Franzen threw it into the middle of the blue paint, where it then got lost in the scrum.

Highlights

Watch from 1:45/1:50 area. Clearly doesn't go in

[hillbillywingsfan 792]

Have to admit, watched the game on TSN last night, showed extensive replays including the overhead. Puck never went in. Never even went near the post so that isn't a puck at 9:40. What happened was he tried wrapping it around too soon, and instead of getting it into the post, Franzen threw it into the middle of the blue paint, where it then got lost in the scrum.

Highlights

Watch from 1:45/1:50 area. Clearly doesn't go in

wft!?!?! thats not even the whole reply. you can;t go by that. it was after frans fell is where it was in.

you donb't even see the push on that reply.

and what is the rule on being pushed into the goalie? is there one stating that the player can be pushed by the other team and still count as a goal?

Edited May 2, 2011 by hillbillywingsfan

[matt198913 932]

Thats a goal. I didn't even notice it on my DVR but thats a goal