76 replies to this topic

[nyqvististhefuture]

i think montreal is nuts and id deal for him in a second , montreal isnt rebuilding the gm says so i was thinking maybe cleary in a package deal but he's got a no trade clause i believe so what about ummm ...

pk subban and travis moen

for

jakub kindl , patrick eaves and cory emmerton

travis moen could replace eaves , he did really well in anaheim and babcock was his coach , i think hed be awesome here and he's gritty and hits and is perfect for the playoffs ( im sure he'd resign if we wanted him back ) subban is a big upgrade on kindl id say and as for emmerton he probably wouldnt even be in the lineup when the injuries return, wings are stacked up front for depth .... mursak,nyqvist,conner,brunnstrom so we should be fine

so ....would you trade for subban???

Edited by nyqvististhefuture, 17 January 2012 - 01:19 PM.

[wingsdiehard13]

So if Moen is better than Eaves, and Subban is a big upgrade over Kindl; why would Montreal make this trade? For a 13th forward?

[sputman]

that trade would work for me, sure.

so next year, assuming lidstrom stays and stuart leaves :

lidstrom - white

kronwall - ericsson

subban - smith

[nyqvististhefuture]

So if Moen is better than Eaves, and Subban is a big upgrade over Kindl; why would Montreal make this trade? For a 13th forward?

montreal is stupid ? they traded for gomez , kaberle's awful contract got rid of cammalleri for bourque whos locked up till 2016 that team isnt really thinking too much ... as for moen he is a ufa , eaves is locked up for another 2 years and he wouldnt be a 13th forward in montreal he's way better than nokelainen,blunden,gomez,darche etc... and they'd also get emmerton and kindl who's 6'3 to replace subban (habs are lacking in size)

[dat's sick]

Can't say I've watched many Montreal games this year (or last), but from all I've heard Subban has been awful for quite a while.

[redwingfan19]

No way do i want that side show here, but for fun:

Kindl,Tatar,Conditional 3rd for Subban and Moen.

If Subban can learn to not be an idiot, then his potential could be great.

[GMRwings1983]

For the right deal, I would take him.

[Wings_Dynasty]

Hudler, Miller, Smith, 2nd rounder for Subban and Moen

[Nevermind]

Subban has a lot of attitude problems. But, hey, if there's any team stupid enough to trade him for Ericsson and prospects--it might be Montreal.

Edited by Nevermind, 17 January 2012 - 02:24 PM.

[achildr1]

Hudler, Miller, Smith, 2nd rounder for Subban and Moen

Not a chance. Smith could easily be the next Subban as early as next year. I wouldn't trade Smith for Subban straight up, too much baggage already.

[WorkingOvertime]

Hudler, Miller, Smith, 2nd rounder for Subban and Moen

I wouldn't trade Smith for Subban. Smith has the potential to be a top-pairing mean defensemen. Subban is a good player but IMO Smith is worth more to the Wings. Also, Subban's character is worrisome.

[nyqvististhefuture]

no way would i trade away brendan smith, we need some youth back there incase lidstrom and stuart leave , besides smith there's ot much depth in the d position , id replace kindl for subban and throw in extra if possible and i dont know why people are still mentioning ericsson i think hes done alright this season he's never gonna get 40+ pts .....and as for subban having problems , the kid likes to have fun the whole montreal media is uptght , besides what better team to teach subban the ropes???<br>

Edited by nyqvististhefuture, 17 January 2012 - 02:30 PM.

[Heaten]

Brad Stuart straight up?

[Bring Back The Bruise Bros]

I don't like Subban, but if he were to stick to playing hockey, he is a decent player.

To Detroit:

P.K. Subban
Travis Moen

To Montreal:

Jakub Kindl
Cory Emmerton
Pick

[cusimano_brothers]

In answer to the question: yes.

[Hockeytown0001]

No. There's a reason why Montreal is growing tired of him.

[sleepwalker]

No thanks.


Kid seems like a bit of a prima donna to me. Thats not what the Wings need on their team.

[akustyk]

kid has talent, but do you think he'd fit into Wings dressing room? isn't he actually known for causing tension with other players, because if so then I'd surely not want Wings to risk introducing dressing room cancer.

I like his skills but am not convinced that he fits with the Wings.

[wingslogo19]

Oh hell no

[Tim.D]

He won't be traded.