Lids is a given. He's all that and a bucket of cheese. There is no better.
The next closest would be Pasha. If he continues to amaze and spends the rest of his career here, it is possible. I won't say yes, but I sure won't count him out yet.
I would like it if there was some sort of a secondary honouring system for guys like Ozzie, Drapes, Malts, Hank, Mac, Probie... guys who played a huge role in Red Wings history and were fan faves. Certainly not jersey retirement- that is just for the creme de la creme.
It's these along the wall of the entrance to the locker room or something like that.
Obviously if you're special enough to have your number in the rafters then you get both a banner that forever reserves the number and a plaque.