I'm saying it was a broken play. Cleary had a 50/50 shot at who he should cover.
Quincey covers the pass. Typically that means he stays in the middle. If Quincey stays in the middle to cover the pass, then Sharp could've walked in on the left side for a quality shot and you guys would be bashing Cleary for not covering him.
It's only in retrospect because Q made a sliding play towards Sharp that it seems obvious Cleary should've picked up the trailer.
I'm not defending Cleary. I'm pointing out that play was on Smith. But because Cleary is the scapegoat this year you'll even bash him for not guessing correctly on a broken play.