Jump to content


dirtydangles's Photo

dirtydangles

Member Since 23 Dec 2009
Offline Last Active Yesterday, 09:26 PM
-----

#2502727 Legwand to Detroit for Eaves, Jarnkrok + cond 3rd/2nd

Posted by dirtydangles on 28 March 2014 - 09:22 PM

Haha just saw

Congrats Nashville fans ! Keep it going and with any luck we pulled a habs and gifted a McDonough type prospect away

I literally felt like I was going to puke when I found out we traded him. I pray to god this isn't a sign of things to come. 




#2502721 Legwand to Detroit for Eaves, Jarnkrok + cond 3rd/2nd

Posted by dirtydangles on 28 March 2014 - 08:59 PM

Another assist so far tonight - 5 points in 5 games. +5. 




#2502138 3/27 GDT - Canadiens 5 vs. Red Wings 4

Posted by dirtydangles on 27 March 2014 - 07:38 PM

Wow, we never played him in the NHL and traded him to a team that's already playing him and he's already got a goal + assist?  Wow.  Already better than Legwand (by far, considering how many penalities Legwand's taken).  In 3GP he has 1G 3A +5.

3 assists, 1 goal, one shootout goal. 4 points in 4 games so far - we got excited about nyquist when he did similar things.




#2500242 3/23 GDT: Red Wings vs Wild

Posted by dirtydangles on 23 March 2014 - 09:19 PM

Guys if a particular poster is bothering you just add them to your profile block. Don't revert to feeding the troll or insulting it. 




#2500206 3/23 GDT: Red Wings vs Wild

Posted by dirtydangles on 23 March 2014 - 09:09 PM

Also if you don't like what certain posters are posting just block them in your preferences.




#2499296 Is the Real Brendan Smith Finally Starting the Show Up?

Posted by dirtydangles on 22 March 2014 - 04:08 PM

Yeah, he's actually looked much better since that perfect pass to Ryan Smyth.

 

But to keep the nitpickers happy...why the hell did he kick the puck loose in the dying seconds? It could have given Minny a scoring chance at the very end there.

He killed like 10 seconds before that with the refs yelling to move the puck so I wasn't too upset. Shoulda had 2 goals tonight with the assist if the refs didn't go fully mental tonight. 




#2499292 3/22 GDT : Red Wings 3 at Wild 2

Posted by dirtydangles on 22 March 2014 - 04:07 PM

lol babs was hilarious in the interview - thought it was the 80s when kronner came back




#2499270 Is the Real Brendan Smith Finally Starting the Show Up?

Posted by dirtydangles on 22 March 2014 - 03:50 PM

Cmon kip - even you have to admit Smith was great tonight... building on previous games like I think he has been doing lately. Showed up on the scoresheet tonight for you too.




#2499110 3/22 GDT : Red Wings 3 at Wild 2

Posted by dirtydangles on 22 March 2014 - 03:14 PM

Goose is loose




#2499050 3/22 GDT : Red Wings 3 at Wild 2

Posted by dirtydangles on 22 March 2014 - 02:41 PM

Sheahan is such an outstanding passer - last night his pass to Tatar was outrageous too




#2498774 Is the Real Brendan Smith Finally Starting the Show Up?

Posted by dirtydangles on 21 March 2014 - 11:49 PM

 

Yeah the difference is that most rookies do at least one thing pretty well.  Tatar scores, Lashoff kills penalties, and Dekeyser is good defensively.  Smith's an offensive d-man who doesn't score...or play defense.  People don't expect Tatar to be great defensively, people DO expect Smith to be able to pass and play offense and he's not good at that. 

 

As noted above, he starts in the offensive zone more than any of our other defenseman and still only barely scores more than Quincey who starts in the d-zone more than any of our defensemen. 

 

Keep making excuses for Brendan, you're only proving my point.  The stats don't lie.  He's not very good.  And the more you try to make it seem so, the more you show that you're going to defend him no matter what the truth is. 

 

Here's a thought, why don't you tell me all the ways that Smith is better than Quincey, or Dekeyser, or Lashoff...and I'll post links to tell you how wrong you are.  Or I could just do it for you...

 

Smith's gritty:  Lashoff and Quincey have more hits and blocked shots.

Smith's Offensive:   Quincey has more goals, and Dekeyser has more points.

Smith's safer:  Nope. leads the defense in turnovers.

Smith's versatile:  Nope, doesn't play any special teams.

 

Smith only does one thing better than the rest of our defense...turn the puck over.  Everybody else has at least one thing over him.  But keep telling me how good he is and how bad they suck.


 

Dekeyser and Lashoff are both rookies, why don't they suck as bad as Smith defensively if it's merely a product of being young?  Lashoff's better defensively, and Dekeyser is better offensively AND defensively (while playing fewer games).  Being young's not an excuse.  Smith is young AND bad (right now).

You can stick to your stats - I'll watch the on-ice product. Smith has outstanding passing and you say he doesn't - the guy goes tape to tape on the majority of them - Quincey's passing is below average at best. Smith is a great skater and last night Mickey was saying how he can keep up with Crosby and specifically showed the play where Smith smothered Crosby entering the zone and came out in control with the puck. Smith shows spark and instinct in jumping into the play offensively that only Kronner shows on this team (this is a thing you see on the ice rather than in the stats sheet). Another thing Smith does better than others is being physical and initiating contact - he is one the best of our D at reversing a hit and staying steady along the boards under contact (I remember Smith reversing a hit on Boby Ryan in the playoffs among others). I'm not saying Smith is amazing (he could be some day) - but your attitude towards s***ting on him completely is unfounded - especially now when he is playing much better. Smith does do many things well and you have to give him credit for them even if it isn't in the goals column or his +/-. 

 

Oh and if you are throwing around stats and my previous paragraph meant nothing to you - Smith 15pts -3, Quincey 12 pts -3 so NO quincey is not better offensively by your statistical standards - goal scoring isn't the only factor. The -3 statistic (even though I don't really care for stats but you do) is the same as Quincey's showing they are equal in terms of being on the ice for bad and good events. Smith outscores Quincey with less ice time this season. The lame thing about stats is you can pick and choose which ones help your personal vendetta and ignore the rest - that is why I generally dislike them. Players give you a "feel" when you watch them every night and Smith has been sending good vibes lately (I know its not objective but if you watch enough games you can see players trend up and down). I trust that much more than the stats sheet and I think most people have the same feeling that Smith has done well lately. I come to threads like this right after the game - when the feeling is still fresh - and post about how I feel a player did - many others do too. Sure - if I want to know how a random player has been doing on another team that I don't watch, then yes, I have a quick look at the stats - but it doesn't really compare to watching that player. Hell - you'd think Helm is useless by looking at his stats and that we should have Hudler instead. 

 

And to address your point about being good at one thing - I'd rather have the majority of my players be average at everything than outstanding in one category while being terrible in another. Lashoff seems better on D because he never commits to making anything happen in the offensive zone so he is always positioned to succeed defensively - its no that hard to figure that out. DD is a more polished player than smith right now - there is no way around that. Smith is not bad - he is developing and learning to use his tools. 




#2498311 3/20 GDT - Penguins 4 at Red Wings 5 (OT)

Posted by dirtydangles on 20 March 2014 - 09:17 PM

f*** yeah




#2498233 3/20 GDT - Penguins 4 at Red Wings 5 (OT)

Posted by dirtydangles on 20 March 2014 - 09:07 PM

How about Glendening out there?  He's composed... glad to see the kid out there in a huge situation and do good :)

Glendening just doesn't give a f*** - thats his composure - the kid just competes. 




#2498135 3/20 GDT - Penguins 4 at Red Wings 5 (OT)

Posted by dirtydangles on 20 March 2014 - 08:54 PM

Shut down the 3rd pairing for the night please babs 




#2498069 3/20 GDT - Penguins 4 at Red Wings 5 (OT)

Posted by dirtydangles on 20 March 2014 - 08:47 PM

I'm thinking Glendening finally scores tonight off of some crazy deflection. 

was i right?

 

EDIT I guess luke didn't touch it?