Most complete player. I feel like I've heard it said he's the most rounded player for a few years now. Whether that translates into being "better" than Malkin and Crosby and their offensive numbers is obviously debatable.
Best two-way player. Outside of this forum, not many people have said he's a better player than Crosby or Malkin, or should be rated higher.
Seems like people now think Tayes is the best two-way player in the game.
Toews is a better two way player than them. Is that even in question? I don't recall Malkin and Crosby being highly regarded for their defensive game. Or have I been under a rock too long?
Crosby and makin are still better than toews IMO. The thing that he is better is in leadership.
On topic though I don't have the freshest memories of Fedorov. I was pretty young. I think Datsyuk gets in the hall of fame though.