Jump to content

Dabura's Photo


Member Since 27 Feb 2004
Offline Last Active Private

#2562553 Jimmy Howard.......All-Star!

Posted by Dabura on 11 January 2015 - 09:29 PM

For the record, I have total faith in Mrazek.

#2562524 Lines Thread

Posted by Dabura on 11 January 2015 - 06:42 PM

If the second pair is just going to be a shutdown pair anyway, and provide relatively little offense, what do you guys think about moving dekeyser up with knonwall, and putting Ericsson with Quincey? I agree that Q and dekeyser have been good defensively, but if we can't figure out a transition game then I think we are going to continue to struggle.


My concern there is it takes away our steadiest pairing (which, granted, isn't saying much) and gives us two third pairings. Kronwall carries Ericsson, DeKeyser carries Quincey, so...our shutdown pair is the two guys who need to be carried by superior puck-movers? That sounds like a possession black hole. Lots of shot-blocking and hitting and shutting down and defending, sure, but only because they'd never have the puck.


But really, any way you arrange it, our D corps just isn't good enough. Replacing Kindl with Petry would be a start, I guess.


Kronwall  Petry

DeKeyser  Quincey

Smith  Ericsson

God, our blue line. woof. Seriously. woof.

#2562444 Do we need a trade to get our offence going ?

Posted by Dabura on 11 January 2015 - 05:22 AM

He wants to score, that's it.


Nope. Watch him play. Going back to that game against the Blackhawks, for example...




#10 Nail Yakupov, 8. Finished a hard check on Brent Seabrook as the Chicago defenceman cycled the puck to Duncan Keith; Keith gave the puck away and Pouliot cashed in for Edmonton’s first goal of the night…


tried to pass across to Roy but it was blocked and the puck almost bounced right into the Chicago net…


made a bad giveaway to create a shorthanded rush for Chicago but recovered [My note: didn't just recover. Skated as hard as he could on the backcheck] and broke up the play in the Oilers’ zone…


He hits, backchecks, and tends to pass when he should shoot. That's him in 2014-15. I'd actually say his play with the puck has been more concerning than his play without it.


He's a good kid who's learning to play the right way.

#2562257 Do we need a trade to get our offence going ?

Posted by Dabura on 10 January 2015 - 02:57 PM

What's wrong with Yakupov: drafted by and plays for the Edmonton Oilers.


He had a shift last night - against the Blackhawks - where he hauled ass on the backcheck and got back just in time to break up a 'hawks scoring chance. He also had an assist and a beautiful goal-scorer's goal.


He's a great kid. His heart's in the right place. He could be a partyer and a womanizer and an egotistical punk, but that's not him. He's religious, hangs out with his mom.


He just needs a change of scenery, an organization that knows what it's doing, has its act together.

#2562202 McGratton on waivers

Posted by Dabura on 10 January 2015 - 05:49 AM

Zetterberg - Datsyuk - McGrattan

#2561419 Mike Yeo (Wild) Has Meltdown At Practice

Posted by Dabura on 07 January 2015 - 07:48 PM

I'm sure J.P. Parise's situation doesn't make things any easier. Awful stuff. :(

#2561395 Nyquist Fined for Diving/Embellishment

Posted by Dabura on 07 January 2015 - 06:20 PM

By that rationale we should be ok with it if one of our guys cheap shots someone in the head.  Ya know, because other people do it too. 


I'm a proponent of having higher standards than that. 


Hitting someone in the head and embellishing are slightly different things.


I think you're being a bit too hard-line about this. Diving sucks, but it's a thing. That's why they're doing this fining system - it's gotten slightly out of control and the league wants to clamp down on it. (Granted, the same can be said of hits to the head. But, again, I'll take a dive over a shot to someone's head. Not that I condone either one, mind you.)

#2561390 Nyquist Fined for Diving/Embellishment

Posted by Dabura on 07 January 2015 - 06:16 PM

Sheeesh you guys act like that never happens and he's not the only one doing it.  


Yeah, if we're being honest, pretty much everyone does it. Or, put another way, no one's totally above it.

#2561370 Nyquist Fined for Diving/Embellishment

Posted by Dabura on 07 January 2015 - 05:11 PM

Here's the NJ one:




He definitely deserves the fine. I just hate that it's a Wing.

#2561009 Randy Carlyle relieved of his duties by Leafs

Posted by Dabura on 06 January 2015 - 05:12 PM








#2560631 Pens aquire David Perron from Oilers

Posted by Dabura on 04 January 2015 - 06:32 PM

I disagree with this to a point (although I wouldn't mind swapping a left handed shooter for a right handed shooter).  Adding 20 goal scorers is nice, but I don't think the issue with scoring comes down to who we have on forward, how our forwards are playing, or even the coaching schemes that they're playing under.  The way I'm seeing our games play out, it all comes down to the fact that we don't have any real offensive threat aside from Kronwall from our defense.  If you look at goals scored (or even points) from the blue line, the Wings are close to the bottom of the league, especially for a playoff team.  Other teams know this and they're playing more aggressively down low in the defensive end instead of playing more tightly to our defenders, which gives our forwards less time and space to work with.  (For the record I think this is more of the causative agent why the Wings are labeled as a perimeter offense team, and not the notion that we need more power forwards).  And if we play it back to the blueline, they know as well as we do the puck likely isn't getting to the net.  They can afford to give our defenders that extra second with the puck.  I even think that our coaching staff has tried to adapt to this weakness by using our defense more as an outlet to get the puck from one side of the zone to the other, instead of forcing a shot through (I have no solid data or quotes to back this up, I've just noticed a lot more winger->defender->opposite winger/opposite defender plays than winger->defender-> shot on net plays this season.  I could be entirely wrong on this).  Anyway, if we spend the assets to get Perron, we're down those assets, we're down the roster player that Perron is replacing, we're down that chemistry the players have established until Perron gets comfortable, and there's no guarantee that Perron even gets comfortable in our system.  And in light of how other teams defend against us, I'm not even confident saying that Perron is a 20 goal scorer here.  Acquiring him certainly won't change how other teams defend against us, although it might make it easier to rip a one-timer from the half wall on the left side, or break out of our zone under pressure from the left side, which does have its values. 

On the other hand, if we can somehow acquire someone who can, at the very least, put pucks on the net from the blue line with some consistency, I think we will see production go up throughout the entire team, because in addition to what the defender can make happen (goals, shots that are tipped in, etc) I think it will open up some space for our forwards as opposing wingers will have more to worry about from our blueline for them to cheat on their coverage.

So I guess my main beef is that I don't think acquiring Perron will make much of a difference in the trajectory of this team, and I'd rather see our assets go towards an offensive defensman, whom I do think can be a real difference maker.


Don't get me wrong, I'm all about adding an offensive defenseman. We struggle to score primarily because our defensemen struggle to move the puck and shoot the puck and put up points. Ericsson is a shutdown defenseman. Quincey is a shutdown defenseman. DeKeyser is a shutdown defenseman. We want to play the way we played in '08 and '09, but we don't have the blue line for it. We had one straight-up shutdown defenseman in that top four (Stuart) and three all-star offensive defensemen (Lidstrom, Rafalski, Kronwall). Now we just have Kronwall. That's not nearly good enough. That's why we run around in our end. It's why we trudge through the middle of the ice, often settling for just clearing the red line so we can dump it in and get a line change. It's why our power play often sucks. It's why we aren't a high-scoring team.


But we also don't have enough scoring depth up front. Even when we had Lidstrom and Rafalski and we'd just won the Cup, we thought it was worth adding Hossa. That gave us Datsyuk in his prime, Zetterberg in his prime, Franzen in his prime, Hossa in his prime, and good secondary scorers in Samuelsson, Cleary, and Filppula. (And even then, we came up short that year.) At present, we have an old Datsyuk, and old Zetterberg, Nyquist (can he be a major factor in the playoffs?), Tatar (can he be a major factor in the playoffs?), and sometimes an old Franzen (when he feels like showing up). Jurco is a possession monster, but he's not a significant scoring threat (yet). Helm's not a goal scorer. Abdelkader's having a career year, but he's not a goal scorer. Miller and Glendening don't score. The jury's out on Weiss. Sheahan's a stud, but he's not a goal scorer. I get that adding a scoring winger isn't going to fix this team's fundamental problems, but there's no such thing as too much scoring depth. If we're not going to put our late first-round pick towards a top-end defenseman like Yandle, if we're not going to use it on a rental like Green, if we're going to use it to select a pimple-faced teenager who won't be a real factor for the Wings until 2019, I think we should consider adding a gritty right-shot scoring winger. If we're loading up for a deep run (and I'm not sure that we are), better safe than sorry. Depth, depth, depth. It matters.


And at some point we do have to add some righties. That's another reason why we don't move the puck as well as we'd like - everyone's a left shot. It's a wonder we move the puck as well as we do, actually.

#2560610 CapGeek shuts down

Posted by Dabura on 04 January 2015 - 04:04 PM

As someone who deals with health issues (kidney stones, back pain...) on a daily basis, I can understand and respect his decision. Ultimately, it's just a website, and hockey is just a game. Health and family and quality of life is all that really matters.


I hope everything works out for him. He'll be in my thoughts and prayers.

#2560607 1/3 GDT : Red Wings 1 at Canucks 4

Posted by Dabura on 04 January 2015 - 03:04 PM

Miller stood on his head, our special teams failed us, and man oh man oh man do we need help on the back end.

#2560298 Pens aquire David Perron from Oilers

Posted by Dabura on 03 January 2015 - 01:10 PM

Why the hell would the Wings want David Perron?  You guys are acting like we've lost out on some huge need here.  Perron is a good player, but he's not some big, goal scoring, power forward.  He's an smallish, offensive, skilled player.  We've got so many of those that Stephen Weiss is currently playing on the fourth line.  We have ZERO need for David Perron, so lets not cry over spilled milk. 


He's a right-shot winger in the prime of his career who scored 30 goals for the Oilers. (He got lucky. He'll never score 30 again. But still.) He plays with an edge, likes to agitate, goes to the dirty areas, is a pain in the ass to play against - but he's also skilled enough to be considered a goal-scorer. I'd like him as a gritty complementary winger with good scoring upside. His cap hit's good, he's only signed for one more year past this year, so it wouldn't be a major investment. It'd be a late first-rounder for a guy who could add a dimension to our forward corps that we're somewhat lacking. At the very least, he'd give us some more scoring depth. Basically, I'd take Perron over a kid who's seven years away from playing big, meaningful minutes for the Wings (i.e. the kid we would, and will, take with our first-round pick).


I know - "We should use that first-round pick on a defenseman, not David frickin' Perron." I just have zero faith that that's going to happen. We're not getting Myers, we're not getting Yandle, and we won't move a first for a rental (Green). We're going to sit on the pick, because "there's no hockey store." That makes me a sad panda.


The one thing I "like" about not getting Perron is his hips are a major issue. He might be one big hit away from being borderline useless.


...But we all know he's going to be huge for the Pens, because of course he will.

#2560297 Are the Wings a Contender?

Posted by Dabura on 03 January 2015 - 12:44 PM

Also, we've lost some games. True contenders (e.g. Kings, Blues, Bruins) don't lose games. Shawn Thornton was available, but Ken Holland is an idiot and so he let him go to the Panthers. Do you think it's a coincidence that the Panthers have beaten us twice? Thornton and Mitchell and Bolland give them toughness and leadership and character, something the Wings completely lack.


We'll be lucky to make the playoffs.