Jump to content

Echolalia's Photo


Member Since 21 Mar 2007
Offline Last Active Today, 01:20 AM

#2530716 Red Wings Target Mike Green

Posted by Echolalia on 08 July 2014 - 10:33 PM

I'm still trying to get my head around Tatar being nothing more then Hudler?! As soon as he got up to the big club he put on clinics on hard work & determination. You can see when Tatar is on the ice he wants to make something happen and usually did...He won the MVP when they won the Calder, the kid loves to win and it shows. Moving him, Nyquist, or Jurco are my bugga boos

I'm with you. Tatar was very impressive, especially considering it was his rookie season. He may be only 5'10", but he plays like he's 6'2"

#2530348 What's best for Mantha?

Posted by Echolalia on 07 July 2014 - 08:44 AM

Doesn't matter what we think. It is entirely up to Mantha and Holland/Babcock. The later 2 have clearly said he has to earn a spot. Now it is up to Mantha. I think he will earn a spot. 2 reasons: 1. he is that talented 2. we are that thin/weak of a team. We had 1 guy score 20+ goals this year. mantha will do that this year plus. it is the other parts of his game that are the questions: strength, stamina, defense etc....

I don't see it happening this year.  Dominating in the QMJHL isn't equal to dominating in the AHL, and neither necessarily translate to success in the NHL.  The Wings are also saturated with forwards, and I just don't see Babcock and Holland trusting Mantha with a full-time roster spot after observing him for a couple scrimmages over players who have already demonstrated competency at the NHL level throughout the previous season(s). 

BUT what is exciting is the potential for this kid is really high.  I was looking at the QMJHL stats from last year, and two other names besides Mantha popped out at me.  Jonathon Drouin, who actually had a higher ppg than Mantha, but only played in 46 games, and Nikolaj Ehlers, who was the only rookie in the top 20 in scoring, and was actually 4th league-wide with 104 points in 63 games.  Drouin was drafted by the Lightning 3rd overall in the 2013 draft.  Ehlers was drafed by the Jets 9th overall in 2014.  Meanwhile, the Red Wings drafted Mantha 20th overall, and this kid is putting up similar numbers as these other top draft picks whom he's playing against.  These other two kids are also under 6 feet, while Mantha is already around 6'5". So if I had to bet on who would be most likely to continue to succeed in bigger and tougher leagues, I would go with Mantha.

#2529494 Wings sign Kevin Porter to 1-year, 2-way contract

Posted by Echolalia on 02 July 2014 - 01:24 PM

Lol Ya god forbid we lose... What's his name again? I'm sure every gm was banging on his door....

The star level of a player shouldn't matter. You want someone, you sign him. Not wait around so the fans don't get their feelings hurt.

#2529033 2014 Offseason League Signings and Trades

Posted by Echolalia on 01 July 2014 - 07:24 PM

Of course not. Holland only gives up draft picks for valuable players, such as David Legwand and Kyle Quincey. I would have taken Stuart back for that price over giving up nothing to keep Quincey around.

Stuart's career hasn't been what it used to be with us. I'd rather have Quincey.

#2527207 2014 Offseason League Signings and Trades

Posted by Echolalia on 30 June 2014 - 12:50 PM

Not as big as some of the other names here, but it appears Detroit is going to bring back McCollum. I don't mind it, but I hope he doesn't get in the way of Mrazek playing 50-60 games.


This is good. He struggled early on in his pro career, but McCollum has really settled in and could still make something of himself. The Wings are pretty saturated in net for the foreseeable future, but if he can keep developing the way he has, this kid could be a decent trading chip down the road.

#2527162 Ehrhoff or Niskanen

Posted by Echolalia on 30 June 2014 - 10:54 AM

I would prefer Erhoff. I don't know that Niskanen can repeat his offensive success in Detroit (as we don't have a Crosby, Malkin, or Neil), and Erhoff has made a career out of producing those numbers from the back end. He's older and shoots left, but he's also a known commodity. I also think defensively Erhoff is more well rounded.
Also, Erhoff was never beaten in a fight by Crosby:

#2526956 BUF to buy out Christian Ehrhoff

Posted by Echolalia on 29 June 2014 - 02:06 PM

Ericsson has a no trade contract doesn't he? I'd love to see him traded along with Kindl and Franzen to try and get a forward while getting Ehrhoff and Niskanen. Not gonna happen though.


If we do end up with Erhoff and Niskanen, that's two less spots for our defensive prospect pool to take, so in addition to Kindl and Lashoff (who have pretty low trade value), Marchenko, Sproul, Ouellet all become movable assets, because there won't be any room in Detroit.  Sproul I think we need to hold onto, because of his offensive capability and he shoots right, but I don't know how he would break into the lineup if Erhoff and Niskanen are here.

#2526929 NHL Trivia: Part One

Posted by Echolalia on 29 June 2014 - 01:18 PM

I only got 15 right, and spent like 7 minutes trying to figure out how to spell Robitaille

#2526925 Wings to have face to face with Matt Niskanen

Posted by Echolalia on 29 June 2014 - 01:11 PM

I don't think it's that people don't want it, it's just that you knowing your source is legit only benefits you--the rest of us don't know this cat from Adam, and this is the internet. I'd expect the same reaction if it were me, or 55fan, or haroldsnepts, etc. it's fun to hear the rumors, so don't be offended if to the rest of us that's all they are.

for the record i believe everything that 55fan has and will ever say.  On a separate note, did you know that Kronwall is the descendant of a god and his favorite animal is the guinea pig?

#2526893 BUF to buy out Christian Ehrhoff

Posted by Echolalia on 29 June 2014 - 12:17 PM

I don't get why so many seem to think this would be a better signing than Niskanen. Erhoff turns 32 in about a week. he isn't physical at all, average defensively, and hasn't been great offensively either. yes some of that is because of playing with Buff, but overall just average. he is at the age where he is just leaving what should have been the prime years of his career.


Erhoff 32, 6-2/195 LHed, on a good team good for 35-40 points per season, going to make 5+ million and I am sure he is going to be looking for at least 4 years, maybe 5.


Niskanen 27 6-0/210 RHed, on a good team good for 40+ points, strong in his own end, and going to be looking for 6 million on a max term-7 years.


Now if we don't get Niskanen then going after erhoff makes some sense. he is an upgrade over quincy. But at this point he is clearly a second option.


The bottom line is we need a defensman who can get the puck out of our zone efficiently, has some offensive ability, and can run a powerplay.  Erhoff is getting older (although I wouldn't say 32 is old these days), but he still provides the offense abilities that the Wings sorely lack.  Niskanen does also, and he's younger, but he's also unproven, so I guess the question comes down to what you think the lower risk is: signing a long contract to someone who only had one successful year but younger, or signing a long contract to a proven commodity who is older.  Frankly I want both of them.

#2526829 BUF to buy out Christian Ehrhoff

Posted by Echolalia on 29 June 2014 - 09:49 AM

I wonder if Holland can land both of them


Kronwall Erhoff

NIskanen Dekeyser

Smith Ericsson


#2526635 NHL Draft 2014: Rounds 2-7 **MOD WARNING POST 51**

Posted by Echolalia on 28 June 2014 - 12:37 PM

Clearly Holland and co are thinking success in the future will be on the shoulders of big, strong centers who can play a 200 ft game.
After losing repeatedly to the Sharks, and being forced to the outside against Boston, I can't say I disagree with management.

#2526532 Dylan Larkin - Highest draft pick since 1991

Posted by Echolalia on 28 June 2014 - 10:18 AM

All scouting reports about Larkin remind me of another phenom we got in the first round - Cory Emmerton.

Yah!! This kid has all sorts of scouts and professionals saying he's going to be an excellent player, and if history has taught me anything, it's that good scouting repots equal bad players! We should have taken the kid who all the scouts say suck. That's gonna be the next Stamkos.

#2525605 2014 NHL Awards Winners and Losers

Posted by Echolalia on 24 June 2014 - 10:45 PM

stupid that Roy won ... hope Babcock comes back next year with a vengeance.  

I can't argue with the fact that Roy won, considering where the Avs were this year compared to last year, but the Jack Adams has really become "the best coach not named Babcock award".  It still amazes me that he has never won this trophy.

#2525566 2014 NHL Awards Winners and Losers

Posted by Echolalia on 24 June 2014 - 08:05 PM

@TPLhockey: Niklas Kronwall finishes 13th in Norris voting, one spot ahead of Subban and Ekman-Larsson.

I guess that means there's only 12 #1 defensmen in the league