Lilja> Lebda
Lilja isn't the most complete d-man and still makes mistakes (turning over the puck to Selanne). But He does block shots and finish checks. Also one of the moments that sticks out in my mind is when Phaenuf leveled Hudler center ice in the Calgary series last year, Lilja asked Phaneuf to go. Not many of us would want to fight Phaneuf. When I think of Lebda I think of Horrible passing, and How he takes one arm off his stick to press guys against the boards which just turns into a kickfest, very ineffective bump your man and get the puck. Like I said. Lilja > Lebda