We could have the Islander's draft history:
1(5) = 1st round, 5th overall
GP = Games played in the NHL
S = Season(s) with Islanders
PA = People drafted between that position and the following spot that are of note.
I started at the most recent year that we drafted somebody currently on our roster (Abdelkader). I stopped listing Islander picks after the 5th round, just those that were available and are of note. The 1989 draft is interesting.
The longest a player has played for the Islanders since the year he was drafted is around 5 1/2 seasons. That honor goes to Scott Lachance, drafted in 1991. Compare that to to our 53rd overall pick in 1989 - a Mr. Nicklas Lidstrom.
I know a lot of luck goes into drafting, but there seems to be a trend of ineptitude here.
2005
1(15) - Ryan O'Marra
GP - 24
PA - Martin Hanzal, Tukka Rask, T.J. Oshie, James Neal, Justin Abdelkader, Paul Stastny
2(46) - Dustin Kohn
GP - 22
PA - Kris Letang, Mayson Raymond
3(76) - Shea Guthrie
GP - 0
PA - Keith Yandle, Darren Helm
5(144) - Masi Marjamaki
GP - 1
PA - Sergei Kostitsyn
2004
1(16) - Petteri Nokelainen
GP - 189, S - 1
PA - Travis Zajac, Wojtek Wolski, Andrej Meszaros, Mike Green, Dave Bolland
2(47) - Blake Comeau
GP - 245, S - 4
PA - David Krejci
3(82) - Sergei Ogorodnikov
GP - 0
PA - Alexander Edler, Johan Franzen
4(115) - Wes O'Neill
GP - 5
PA - Ryan Callahan, Kris Versteeg
5(148) - Steven Regier
GP - 26
PA - Mikhail Gabrovski, Mark Streit
2003
1(15) - Robert Nilsson
GP - 252, S - 1
PA - Zach Parise, Ryan Getzlaf, Brent Burns, Ryan Kesler, Mike Richards, Corey Perry, Patrick Eaves, Loui Eriksson, Patrice Bergeron, Matt Carle
2(48) - Dmitri Chernykh
GP - 0
PA - Shea Weber
2(53) - Evgeny Tunik
GP - 0
PA - Patrick O'Sullivan
2(58) - Jeremy Colliton
GP - 57
PA - David Backes, Jimmy Howard
4(120) - Stefan Blaho
GP - 0
PA - Lee Stempniak, Joe Pavelski, Dustin Byfuglien
2002
1(22) - Sean Bergenheim
GP - 326, S - 3
PA - Alexander Steen, Jarret Stoll, Matthew Stajan, Jiri Hudler, Tomas Fleischmann
3(87) - Frans Nielsen
GP - 237, S - 3
PA - Matthew Lombardi
5(149) - Markus Pahlsson
GP - 0
PA - James Wisniewski, Maxime Talbot, Dennis Wideman, Petr Prucha
2001
4(101) Cory Stillman (not that one)
GP - 0
PA - Christian Ehrhoff
5(132) - Dusan Salficky
GP - 0
PA - Kyle Wellwood, Marek Zidlicky, Ryan Clowe, Kevin Bieksa, Jussi Jokinen, Brooks Laich, Petr Cajanek
2000
1(1) - Rick Dipietro
GP - 207, S - 3.5
PA - Dany Heatley, Marian Gabori
1(5) - Raffi Torres
GP - 512, S - .25
PA - Scott Hartnell, Alexander Frolov, Anton Volchenkov, Brad Boyes, Justin Williams, Niklas Kronwall, Jarret Stoll, Antoine Vermette, Ilya Bryzgalov, Paul Martin
4(101) - Arto Tukio
GP - 0
PA - NA
4(105) - Vladimir Gorbunov
GP - 0
PA - Lubomir Visnovsky
5(136) - Dmitry Upper
GP - 0
PA - NA
5(148) - Krostoffer Ottosson
GP - 0
PA - John-Michael Liles, Henrik Lundqvist, Matthew Lombardi, Antti Miettinen
1999
1(5) - Tim Connolly
GP - 627, S - 2
PA - NA
1(8) - Taylor Pyatt
GP - 682, S - 1
PA - NA
1(10) - Branislav Mezei
GP - 240, S - .25
PA - Martin Havlat
1(28) - Kristian Kudroc
GP - 26
PA - Niklas Hagman
3(87) - Brian Collins
GP - 0
PA - Mike Comrie
4(101) - Juraj Kolnik
GP - 240, S - .25
PA - NA
4(102) - Johan Halvardsson
GP - 0
PA - Ryan Malone, Ryan Miller, Martin Erat, Henrik Zetterberg, Radim Vrbata
1998
1(9) - Michael Rupp
GP - 0
PA - Nikolai Antropov, Alex Tanguay, Simon Gagne, Scott Gomez
2(36) - Chris Nielsen
GP - 52
PA - Mike Fisher, Mike Ribeiro, Brad Richards, Erik Cole, Brian Gionta, Alexei Ponikarovsky
4(95) - Andy Burnham
GP - 0
PA - Shawn Horcoff, Jaroslav Spacek
5(123) - Jiri Dopita
GP - 73, S - 0
PA - Mikael Samuelsson, Chris Neil, Andrei Markov, Ales Kotalik, Pavel Datsyuk, Michael Ryder
1997
1(4) - Roberto Luongo
GP - 672, S - .25
PA - NA
1(5) - Eric Brewer
GP - 758, S - 1
PA - Sergei Samsonov, Marian Hossa, Danny Cleary, Brendan Morrow
2(31) - Jeff Zehr
GP - 4
PA - Kristian Huselius
3(59) - Jarrett Smith
GP - 0
PA - Maxim Afinogenov
3(79) - Robert Schnabel
GP - 22
PA - Joe Corvo
4(85) - Petr Mika
GP - 3
PA - NA
5(115) - Adam Edinger
GP - 0
PA - Magnus Arvedson, Jason Chimera, Mike York, Matt Cooke, Brian Campbell
1996
1(3) - J.P. Dumont
GP - 822, S - 0
PA - Derek Morris, Dainius Zubrus, Marco Sturm, Daniel Briere
2(29) - Dan LaCouture
GP - 337, S - 0
PA - Matt Cullen, Jan Bulis
3(56) - Zdeno Chara
GP - 928, S - 3
PA - Nobody close to his abilities
4(83) - Tyrone Garner
GP - 3
PA - Eric Belanger, Michal Rozsival
5(109) - Andrew "Bubba" Berenzweig
GP - 37
PA - Pavel Kubina, Willie Mitchell, Tomas Kaberle, Sami Salo
1995
1(2) - Wayne Redden
GP - 994, S - 0
PA - Daymond Langkow, Shane Doan, Radek Dvorak, Jarome Iginla, Peter Sykora
2(28) - Jan Hlavac
GP - 436, S - 0
PA - NA
2(41) - D.J. Smith
GP - 45
PA - Jochen Hecht, Michael Handzus
5(106) - Vladimir Orszagh
GP - 289, S - .25
PA - Mikka Kiprusoff, Jan Hrdina, Stephane Robidas, P.J. Axelsson, Filip Kuba, Danil Markov
1994
1(9) - Brett Lindros
GP - 51
PA - Jeff Friesen, Mattias Ohlund, Ethan Moreau
2(38) - Jason Holland
GP - 81
PA - Patrik Elias
3(63) - Jason Strudwick
GP - 674, S - .25
PA - Fredrik Modin, Sheldon Souray, Chris Dury, Milan Hejduk
4(90) - Brad Lukowich
GP - 658, S - 0
PA - NA
5(112) - Mark McArthur
GP - 0
PA - NA
5(116) - Albie O'Connell
GP - 0
PA - Marty Turco, Danel Alfredsson, Tim Thomas, Evgeni Nabokov, Steve Sullivan, Tomas Holmstrom
1993
1(23) - Todd Bertuzzi
GP - 1022, S - 2.5
PA - Jamie Langenbrunner, Brendan Morrison
2(40) - Bryan McCabe
GP - 1135, S - 2.5
PA - NA
3(66) - Vladimir Chebaturkin
GP - 62
PA - Vaclav Prospal
4(92) - Warren Luhnig
GP - 29
PA - Miroslav Satan
5(118) - Tommy Salo
GP - 526, S - 2.5
PA - Scott Walker, Darcy Tucker, Todd Marchant, Andrew Brunette, Mike Grier, Pavol Demitra, Kimmo Timonen
1992
1(5) - Darius Kasparaitis
GP - 863, S - 3
PA - Cory Stillman, Sergei Gonchar, Martin Straka, Valeri Bure, Mike Peca, Darren McCarty
3(56) - Jarrett Deuling
GP - 15
PA - Kirk Maltby, Craig Rivet, Jere Lehtinen
5(104) - Tomas Klimt
GP - 0
PA - NA
5(105) - Ryan Duthie
GP - 0
PA - Adrian Aucoin, Ian Laperriere, Stephane Yelle, Nikolai Khabibulin
1991
1(4) - Scott Lachance
GP - 819, S - 5.5
PA - Peter Forsberg, Brian Rolston, Alexei Kovalev, Markus Naslund, Glen Murray, Martin Rucinsky, Ray Whitney
2(26) - Zigmund Palffy
GP - 684, S - 3.5
PA - Sandis Ozolinsh, Jozef Stumpel, Yanic Perreault
3(48) - Jamie McLennan
GP - 254, S - .25
PA - Michael Nylander
4(70) - Milan Hnilicka
GP - 121, S - 0
PA - Mike Knuble, Alexei Zhitnik
5(92) - Steve Junker
GP - 5
PA - Sean O'Donnell, Brian Savage
1990
1(6) - Scott Scissons
GP - 2
PA - Darryl Sydor, Derian Hatcher, Brad May, Keith Tkachuk, Martin Brodeur, Bryan Smolinski
2(27) - Chris Taylor
GP - 149, SP - 0
PA - Doug Weight, Geoff Sanderson, Vyacheslov Kozlov
3(48) - Dan Plante
GP - 159, S - 2
PA - Alexei Zhamnov, Sergei Zubov
5(90) - Chris Marinucci
GP - 13
PA - Craig Conroy, Jason York, Robert Lang, Andrei Kovalenko, Peter Bondra
1989
1(2) - Dave Chyzowski
GP - 126, S - 1
PA - Scott Thornton, Stu Barnes, Bill Guerin, Bobby Holik, Mike Sillinger, Olaf Kolzig, Adam Foote
2(23) - Travis Green
GP - 970, S - 4
PA - Patrice Brisebois
3(44) - Jason Zent
GP - 27
PA - Nicklas Lidstrom, Kris Draper
4(65) - Brent Grieve
GP - 97
PA - Sergei Fedorov
5(86) - Jace Reed
GP - 0
PA - NA
5(90) - Steve Young
GP - 0
PA - NA
5(99) - Kevin O'Sullivan
GP - 0
PA - Dallas Drake