Heaton

HoF Booster
  • Content Count

    2,745
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Heaton


  1. I was worried about being too lenient Konnan511 - and your comments confirm my fear. I find it hard to be critical of players on a team that are racking up 80% of the available points, thinking they must all be playing their roles at an above average level or else the team would be average. Like your grades too though and understand your thinking. Thanks for the kind words about the site, please do come back often and as always leave your comments. Mike

    Don't be. I agree with the majority of your grades and while its great to have high standards you need to realize how good this team is.

    One of the major ones I disagree with Konann is about giving Stuart a C- and the only comment being about his point totals. Stuart isn't here to produce offensively, he's here to be solid defensively and physical. He started slow but has been very good lately and is a B at worst.


  2. Babcock gave Hudler all of two games to make it on that line, and despite that line having a lot of success in the preseason, he yanked Hudler pretty immediately in favor of Samuelsson.

    And it seems to have paid off with Hudler and Samuelsson on pace for career seasons. Samuelsson wasn't working with Filppula and Hudler wasn't working with Z/Franzen during even strength. Ever since the lines got switched everything has been gravy.


  3. He dove falling backwards? Interesting. This is all complete overreaction.

    18 games, 14 points, no penalties up until last night. Playing less minutes consistently than he has in years. Did Lidstrom look better last year? Sure. Did he look better in the playoffs? Of course. Is he playing badly by his own standards? Nope. One extra mistake a game doesn't warrant all of this craziness.


  4. How does McCarty hinder our winning?

    We can both win and fight, and from hearing the fans last night, they didn't seem to mind McCarty's actions against Stortini.

    He doesn't, which is why he'll be in the lineup on Thursday. Breath GMR, try and realize the situation before overreacting. McCarty was waived on Oct 20th, he's waived again on November 18th. It's not a coincidence.