DickieDunn

Member
  • Content Count

    4,840
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    30

Everything posted by DickieDunn

  1. DickieDunn

    Apparently it can get worse in Vancouver.

    Detroit has almost that much wrapped up in Datsyuk and Zetterberg. Datsyuk is older and Zetterberg has back issues. The Sedin contracts aren't the problem, the fact that the owner forced Tortorella on him and he's made a lot of other bad choices. They have 5 guys who are even arguably top 6 forwards, one of whom (Burrows) is playing like crap this year, traded a talented player for a big guy with questionable skill and created a hole at the #2 center spot, and has had to trade both of his starting goalies over the last year. Now he has the most overrated coach in the NHL pissing on everyone to the point where his good players want out, and he had no choice in the hire and probably wouldn't be able to get the owner's blessing to fire the guy. At this point he'd probably be better off telling them that either Tortorella goes or he does, taking a year or two of, and looking for a new job.
  2. DickieDunn

    Riley Sheahan - Underappreciated and Overshadowed?

    A lot of Sheahan's increased offense has to do with his role. ND played a defense first system, and with the Grifs he was their shut down center, again focusing more on defense. Now he's being allowed to play more offense, and he's producing. That doesn't mean he's a sure fire #2 center, but I think he can play the grinder role for a couple skilled wingers, like Steve Rucchin did with Anaheim, only to a lesser extent. At worst I think he'll be a big bodied defensive 3rd line guy.
  3. DickieDunn

    Apparently it can get worse in Vancouver.

    $14 mil between them, for 4 years. If Vancouver wants to trade them, they're going to have to take a bunch of money back. Regardless, I can't see them moving the Sedins.
  4. DickieDunn

    Glendening signed to 3 year extension

    It's 3 years. That's pretty standard league wide. Usually the only players on one year deals are older guys at the end of their careers, guys trying to get to a UFA deal with a one year contract, or a guy who has to prove something.
  5. DickieDunn

    Glendening signed to 3 year extension

    capgeek has it at $628,333. He gets a raise and the number is still low enough that he can be sent to GR with no cap penalty.
  6. DickieDunn

    Apparently it can get worse in Vancouver.

    Then Tortorella went into the mess, dropped his pants, took a dump and lit the whole thing on fire.
  7. DickieDunn

    Question about Mantha

    Probably this is true
  8. DickieDunn

    Gustav Nyquist Appreciation Thread

    Franzen scores over 25 and he's a bum. Nyquist isn't shooting more, but he's figured out how to pick his spots.
  9. DickieDunn

    Gustav Nyquist Appreciation Thread

    My only concern is that he's setting people up for unrealistic expectations. He's probably not going to shoot 20% long term so he won't score quite as much.
  10. DickieDunn

    4/2 GDT - Bruins 2 at Red Wings 3

    Wings are lucky they're not down 6-1 right now. Jurco needs to not throw a hit on Boychuk there, Boychuk needs to wake the F--k up and not admire his pass though.
  11. DickieDunn

    Weiss - who would take him next season and does he have a full NTC

    And that's debatable. He scores more, but Weiss is better defensively.
  12. DickieDunn

    Weiss - who would take him next season and does he have a full NTC

    Nobody very good.
  13. DickieDunn

    4/2 GDT - Bruins 2 at Red Wings 3

    Holy bad call Batman. Looks like a call that would go against the Wings.
  14. DickieDunn

    Hypothetical

    I think it's covered int he league by-laws, not the CBA. The CBA covers stuf between the teams and players, not between teams.
  15. DickieDunn

    Hypothetical

    The league can block a trade. Most trades could at least be argued as legit, but if it was something like Ovechkin for a 7th rounder or something it might not fly.
  16. DickieDunn

    Legwand to Detroit for Eaves, Jarnkrok + cond 3rd/2nd

    The fact that Jarnkrok was highly rated means nothing. Here are a couple older RWC prospect rankings. http://www.redwingscentral.com/2009/06/17/916/2008-09-end-of-season-abdelkader-takes-vacated-top-spot/ Abdelkader, Leino, McCollum, Kindl, Smith top 5. http://www.redwingscentral.com/2007/11/07/85/2007-08-preliminary-howard-keeps-grip-on-top-spot/ Howard, Kindl, Abdelkader, Emmerton, Smith top 5. http://www.redwingscentral.com/2005/06/13/94/2005-06-end-of-season-kronwall-still-king/
  17. DickieDunn

    The Edmonton Oilers Mystery

    Remember when the Lions used their top pick on a WR 3 years in a row? That's basically what the oilers have done. Tons of good young forwards, no D or goalie.
  18. DickieDunn

    Is this the worst "fight" of all time?

    If I was the guy's coach, he'd never dress another game for me again.
  19. DickieDunn

    3/30 GDT - Lightning 2 @ Red Wings 3

    Flip has 57 points in 105 career playoff games. He had a couple decent years, 16 pts in 23 games, 9 in 12, 8 in 11, but nothing spectacular. He's also either been hurt or ineffective all but 2 of his 8 full NHL seasons. He was blah his first year, better his second, about the same his 3rd, then good (but hurt), bad, good, bad, good this year. Odds are he's either going to play under 60 games or play in 70+ and score under 40 next year.
  20. DickieDunn

    Legwand to Detroit for Eaves, Jarnkrok + cond 3rd/2nd

    Every team ends up making trades like that occasionally.
  21. DickieDunn

    Legwand to Detroit for Eaves, Jarnkrok + cond 3rd/2nd

    The problem with your argument is that you're starting with it's a mistake, because "GOOD PROSPECT." If he doesn't develop into a top line player, it's not a mistake, it was selling a guy the team cooled on while his value was at its peak.
  22. DickieDunn

    Legwand to Detroit for Eaves, Jarnkrok + cond 3rd/2nd

    Yes they did. I remember people losing their minds over that trade, just like they're losing their minds over Jarnkrok. Just because he was their best center prospect, that doesn't mean he was truly a legit top line center, and the odds are a lot higher that he's going to be a 40 point a year guy than a guy who's going to come in and come close to a point a game. Let me reiterate that the Wings have employees whose main job is to evaluate their own prospects. I don't care how many good things they've said about the kid in the press, they say good things about every prospect. The fact that they were willing to trade him for Legwand tells me that they weren't nearly as high on him as a lot of the fans are. If they were, they could have moved anyone of a number of other kids instead of him.
  23. DickieDunn

    Legwand to Detroit for Eaves, Jarnkrok + cond 3rd/2nd

    You don't get good players for Ferraro, Callahan, Miller, and a 3rd, which is all a lot of the people screaming to make a trade want to give up. Legwand has been the Pred's best forward pretty much his entire career, and is at worst a second line center. Jarnkrok is a 22 year old prospect who the guys who constantly evaluate their prospects and monitor them far more closely and accurately than anyone outside of the organization, much less a random fan posting on a message board, were comfortable trading for Legwand. This reminds me of the rants we heard every time Matthias or any other prospect the Wings gave up had a good game, until a couple years passed and people realized oh, he's not as good as we thought he'd be.
  24. DickieDunn

    Do you want monster to start tomorrow?

    He'll give up 4 goals, Wings will win 5-4, people will say "Monster should be #1 he wins his games," then tomorrow Kahn will tweet that Gustavsson tweaked his groin and will be out 2 weeks.
  25. DickieDunn

    3/29 GDT - Red Wings 4 at Maple Leafs 2

    They're in control of the spot though. 2 points over Washington, 2 points and 2 games in hand over Toronto, and the tie breaker over both teams. All they have to do is win and they're in, Toronto and Washington need to have another team stumble.