DickieDunn

Member
  • Content Count

    4,840
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    30

Everything posted by DickieDunn

  1. Not for 10 games. Coming back onto the ice is a major no-no it's an automatic suspension* *unless it's a star player then the league will uncover some obscure rule that lets them keep said star on the ice
  2. DickieDunn

    The MANtha watch.....

    unfortunately I fear kickazz is right. Holland is going to screw around and try to force them to sign bargain contracts because of cap constraints, probably after he goes out and signs some vet ont he wrong side of 30 to a multi-year deal.
  3. Flames did a lot of crying about the fight, but Kulak and Tkachuk are the ones who started it. That said, that was no spear, he tapped Witkowsli on the leg.
  4. DickieDunn

    The MANtha watch.....

    Should be
  5. DickieDunn

    Rumors Thread

    Ericsson probably could be traded if they added a 3rd round pick and took back a middling prospect or a 4th rounder back. The question becomes should they? I don't think so, unless they actually add someone like Tavares and need the cap space. Sure, the pick you send probably won't amount to much, but it might, and there's no reason to spend an asset just to get rid of a guy. Helm, Glendening, and Abdelkader can help a team. Not many people dispute that. The problem is their bloated contracts, not them as players. Maybe, maybe not. It's your opinion that they WOULD. I think there would be better, younger options for other teams.
  6. Smith is too dumb to realize he's not all that good. Sad, really.
  7. DickieDunn

    The MANtha watch.....

    it was after my time. I do remember watching the show that got the anime ball rolling in the US.
  8. DickieDunn

    2017 Draft

    so what? That just means he isn't ready yet, not that he's not going to be good.
  9. DickieDunn

    11/05 GDT : Detroit Red Wings @ Edmonton Oilers : 4:00 PM ET

    Put Frk with guys who can provide some offense and he produces. Still kind of one dimensional, but as long as he's used correctly he can help the team. Along with Ericsson, Kronwall, Holland, and Blashill
  10. DickieDunn

    Rumors Thread

    How many teams trade a first at the deadline anymore, especially for a guy over 30 with an expiring deal? There's no way he brings a first round pick in a trade. Being dead last doesn't guarantee anything, but it gives you the best chance at #1 and means you can't pick below 4th. Wings had another #4 overall turn out to be pretty good. It's certainly better than another pick in the 10-15 range.
  11. DickieDunn

    Rumors Thread

    My cousin's friend's brother's neighbor knows Holland's wife's hairdresser's roommate and I have confirmation that keeping Blashill as coach is an effort at tanking without looking like he's tanking.
  12. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    Jensen should go back, or better yet just waive and release him outright
  13. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    It takes 24 hours for him to clear, they need to put him through every 30 days (or something like that) so he can be sent down immediately if they need to recall someone else.
  14. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    Name one defenseman currently on the Wings roster who's from Sweden and whose last name begins with the letter E who is better than Ericsson. Well, I'm waiting. Can't name anyone? OK, that proves Ericsson isn't really that bad and anyone who doesn't think he should be on the PP is just spewing blind hatred. #kickazzlogic Only when he's pulling one. he sucks playing it.
  15. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    "I'm going to ignore 90% of the point you're making and demand you answer this one part within a narrowly defined window that makes it almost impossible for you to refute what I said." -Kickazz in 95% of his responses You can't argue that the PP is effective and that a different system that doesn't rely on parking a lump in front of the net might work, so you ignore that and demand "who's better than Abdelkader????????????" and blow off any suggestion that doesn't match what you're saying.
  16. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    Anyone else. Someone with hands. Homer wasn't effective because he was big, he was effective because he spent hours on end practicing tipping shots. They don't have anyone effective in that role. Mantha could be with some work, but he's better off in the slot where he can shoot. But, as I've said and KRS said, the system isn't working. It needs to change. Generate traffic by people moving in and out of the crease area, make the goalie move around and find a hole created by the movement. But Trollhunter knows all. He has spoken. So let it be written, so let it be done.
  17. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    Is the current system working? Nope. Change it. Abdelkader isn't good enough to do that. The other guys who are big/willing enough aren't suited for it either. The point of having someone there is to generate traffic and screens, there are other, better ways to do that. Doing something that doesn't work for you because that's how you've "always" done it or other people do it that way is asinine. If it doesn't work, change it.
  18. DickieDunn

    Mrazek "Maturing, could bounce back like Howard"

    When Howard is on and healthy, he's one of the better goalie in the league. When he's off, he's terrible, and he gets hurt every year. Put all those factors together, and he's mediocre because he can't be counted on to be your #1 all year. If someone wants to argue that his good periods make him better than mediocre, that's their opinion.
  19. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    there's someone on redwingcenter that uses that exact same pic
  20. DickieDunn

    Michael Rasmussen

    Tippet is being screwed up. Send him to juniors or play him. I've made the point that putting up points in lesser leagues doesn't always mean much. My point here was that Rasmussen isn't close to being dominant. As far as the preseason game goes, it was one game with a motivated kid against guys who's concern was getting their timing down and not getting hurt.
  21. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    who says you need to have someone standing in front of the net like that? Just because it was effective with Homer out front tipping Lidstrom's shots doesn't mean you keep doing it with less effective players. It's not working, they need to do something different. Or don't, actually. Tank it baby!
  22. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    that's like being the tallest person in Munchkin land.
  23. DickieDunn

    Michael Rasmussen

    So do dumb ones. So do lazy ones. Are his PIM coming because he's hitting and fighting, because he's taking dumb penalties, or because he's being lazy defensively and using his stick to hook and hold? Not that Rasmussen really has a ton, 12 PIM in 10 games. It's far too early to say for sure Rasmussen was good or bad, but based on what he did in his draft year, I don't like the pick. He looked more like a David Clarkson type, and that's not what you want from the 9th overall pick when you're rebuilding and need someone who can be an elite player. 12 points in 10 games isn't really fantastic for a guy who was drafted that high and went back to juniors, either. I'm glad he has some assists, that's encouraging, but it's not dominating either. 75 players have more points. Most have played more games, but not that many. Tyler Steenbergen is leading the WHL with 35 points in 13 games. Four other players are at 30 or better. He's 4th on his team, again with fewer games, but Jordan Topping has a better PPG average. Saying he's outperforming a guy who hasn't played in Vilardi so that means he's better is ridiculous. Tippet vs. Rasmussen: Tippet is in the NHL, Rasmussen is in the WHL. Comparing their stats isn't even apples and oranges, it's apples and rocks.
  24. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    Helm, Glendening, and the rest of the PKere are going to play more in games with more penalties. Abdelkader should be nowhere near a PP unit though. So far, ES TOI breakdown: Zetterberg 17:26 Going to get worn down Nyquist 15:20 too much Tatar 15:12 too much Larkin 14:36 not enough Mantha 14:16 not enough Abdelkader 13:53 too much Helm 12:37 about right Nielsen 11:42 not enough AA 11:31 not enough Frk 9:29 needs to play more but only as the situation allows it. Never out there for D-zone draws or last 5 minutes when leading. Glendening 7:50 about right
  25. DickieDunn

    2017-18 Lines Thread

    Bowman usually had a center and a wing who more or less stuck together, and the 3rd guy would move around. Bowman was also one of, if not the best, coaches in NHL history. Blashill is clueless.