Not only did Seider win the calder in his D+3, he was a legit #1 NHL D.
Eddog isn't likely to even make the team in his D+3. And its questionable that hes even the #1 in GR this season with McIsaac, Johansson, and Rafferty on the team.
I like Edvinsson as much as anyone, and I expect him to be a top4 D for us one day, but he hasnt even knocked on the door of being a #1 yet. Seider kicked that door in day 1.