Favorite to least Favorite Wings Players

[e_mcgrath88 0]

Pav Datsyuk

Nick Lidstrom

Tom Holmstrom

Chris Osgood

Chris Chelios

Chris Draper

Kirk Maltby

Tom Kopecky

Henrik Zetterberg

Johan Franzen

Dan Cleary

Nik Kronvall

Val Filppula

Dom Hasek

Brian Rafalski

Mike Samuelson

Andreas Lilja

Brett Lebda

Aaron Downey

Jiri Hudler

Dallas Drake

Matt Ellis

Derek Meech

Mark Hartigan

[skacore 2]

I would break my favourite to least favourite into 3 groups, no specific order within the groups

Pavel Datsyuk

Niklas Kronwall

Dallas Drake

Aaron Downey

Daniel Cleary

Nicklas Lidstrom

Henrik Zetterberg

Andreas Lilja

Valtteri Filppula

Tomas Kopecky

Tomas Holmstrom

Matt Ellis

Brian Rafalski

Dominik Hasek

Kris Draper

Chris Osgood

Mikael Samuelsson

Kirk Maltby

Mark Hartigan

Derek Meech

Johan Franzen

Brett Lebda

Jiri Hudler

[Wings_Dynasty 267]

I'll just stick to regular starters. By number seems faster.

13

40, 5

30

20

96

18

33

11

24

39

93

28

17

51

82

26

3

55

22

37

Edited January 22, 2008 by Wings_Dynasty

[zata40 3]

I cant do it, I love them all

[Yc172 3]

I'll give you my favorite and least favorite and skip everyone in between

Favorite- Tie between cleary, hank, pav, lidstrom, maltby, draper, and osgood

Least Favorite- Pain Train

[Uncle Danny 155]

Lidstrom

Zetterberg

Draper

Datsyuk

Cleary

Osgood

Filppula

Maltby

Chelios

Holmstrom

Rafalski

Kronwall

Hasek

Drake

Hudler

Downey

Lebda

Samuelson

Lilja

Franzen

Kopecky

Ellis

Meech

Hartigan

[BeeRYCE 2]

Zetterberg

Lidstrom

Datsyuk

Cleary

Chelios

Osgood

Holmstrom

Rafalski

Filppula

Kronwall

Downey

Hudler

Draper

Franzen

Hasek

Maltby

Drake

Kopecky

Lilja

Meech

Hartigan

Ellis

Sammuelsson (The only Wing I don't like)

Edited January 22, 2008 by BeeRYCE

[FedorovGurl 2]

Wow... took me a couple of "root beers" to come up with a list but here goes -

Holmstrom

Lidstrom

Zetterberg

Hudler

Filppula

Chelios

Draper

Osgood

Maltby

Datsyuk

Rafalski

Kronwall

Downey

Lilja

Cleary

Lebda

Drake

Franzen

Kopecky

Hasek

Samuelsson

[BeeRYCE 2]

Looks like I'm one of the bigger Rafalski fans here.

[Kira 451]

I don't have a least favorite because I love them all, but when it comes to favorite, it's Pasha by a long shot.

[Mudvayneowns91 0]

Dats

Lids

Homer

Hank

Draper

Dom

Ozzie

Cleary

Lebda

Cheli

Rafs

Flips

Franzie

Maltby

Huds

Least fav probably Sammy, Ellis or Kopecky

[irishtemper14+25 11]

im one of the few who really like huds

[Mudvayneowns91 0]

I definitely think I'm one of the few that likes Lebda.

[interminded 1]

What kind of thread is this ???

Are we that bored ?

[Aussie_Wing 354]

im one of the few who really like huds

What's there not to like about Huds?

[Feldmarschall 9]

I like most of our guys just fine, but here are my standouts on either extreme.

Top:

Zetterberg

Lidstrom

Holmstrom

Datsyuk

Cleary

Chelios

Bottom:

Samuelsson - Bad mental game

Hasek - Cringe whenever he handles the puck

Drake - Invisible most nights

Lilja - Softer than he should be and turnover-prone

Meech - Bad mental game

That said, all this hate for Hartigan makes no sense to me. What more can we expect from a career reserve forward? He does a fine job.

[Reds4Life 51]

Lids, Zata, Pasha, Cheli, Kronner, Drapes, Malts, Homer

Cleary, Filppula, Rafalski, Hašek, Osgood

Drake, Hudler, Downey, Lebda, Samuelsson, Lilja, Franzen

Kopecky, Ellis, Meech, Hartigan

[BeeRYCE 2]

I like most of our guys just fine, but here are my standouts on either extreme.

Top:

Zetterberg

Lidstrom

Holmstrom

Datsyuk

Cleary

Chelios

Bottom:

Samuelsson - Bad mental game

Hasek - Cringe whenever he handles the puck

Drake - Invisible most nights

Lilja - Softer than he should be and turnover-prone

Meech - Bad mental game

That said, all this hate for Hartigan makes no sense to me. What more can we expect from a career reserve forward? He does a fine job.

It's not hate for Hartigan, it's who cares about Hartigan. I don't hate any player, as a matter of fact the only players I hate in the league are Pronger, Perry, Tucker, and McCabe. HATE is a strong word.

[Zion 93]

The Mother of all Favorite Red Wing Lists:

1) "Norris Nick" Lidstrom

2) Captain America - a.k.a. Chris Chelios

3) "Fearless" Dan Cleary

4) "The Wizard" Pavel Datsyuk

5) "Hank" Zetterberg

6) "The Wizard of Oz"

7) Kris "Drapes"

8) "Val" Filppula

9) Aaron Downey - keeps games cleaner, fresher

10) One man, one name: "Homer"

[55fan 5,133]

Oh! What a delightful way to put off homework and housework! Thank you!

(#1 reserved for DMac should he come back)

Kronner

Zata

Ozzie

Flip

Malts

Drapes

Nick

Dom

Homer

Downey

Drake

Dats

Sammy

Cheli

Cleary

Rafalski

Franzen

Hudler

Lebda

Kopecky

Lilja

Ellis

Not including Meech and Hartigan- not enough info.

[BeeRYCE 2]

What kind of thread is this ???

Are we that bored ?

The weather outside is ridiculously cold, and if I'm home from work/school... I'm here doing nothing, so yeah, I'm that bored... and I think I can speak for others.

Edited January 22, 2008 by BeeRYCE

[b.shanafan14 733]

Wings I love (for the most part):

Zetterberg

Datsyuk

Lidstrom

Osgood

Filppula

Chelios

Rafalski

Holmstrom

Cleary

Draper

Kronwall

Hudler

Kopecky

Lebda

Maltby

Downey

Franzen

Drake

Wings I hate (for the most part):

Hasek (*nearly harmless shot, pointless flop* Great save Hasek! .... still on the ice looking for it.... its in the slot.... come on Dom get up.... GET THE F*** UP!.... please! its not underneith you! GOAL..... *Hasek complains to the ref*)

Lilja (I'm actually more luke-warm about Lilja, I think I'm over the fact that he is terrible defensively and now I just enjoy the running joke of him as an enforcer haha)

Samuelson (Savardian Spin-o-rama, blind pass to the defender. Looking, looking! He has Zetterberg trailing, open passing lane.....!.... and he puts a shot wide, high and out of play, faceoff in the neutral zone...)

Edited January 22, 2008 by b.shanafan14

[FedorovGurl 2]

Whatta ya mean about no love for Hudler?? I have him on my top 5!! Jeez.

[CdnWingsFanEh 2]

Pav Datsyuk

Nick Lidstrom

Tom Holmstrom

Chris Osgood

Chris Chelios

Chris Draper

Kirk Maltby

Tom Kopecky

Henrik Zetterberg

Johan Franzen

Dan Cleary

Nik Kronvall

Val Filppula

Dom Hasek

Brian Rafalski

Mike Samuelson

Andreas Lilja

Brett Lebda

Aaron Downey

Jiri Hudler

Dallas Drake

Matt Ellis

Derek Meech

Mark Hartigan

Henrik Zetterberg

Pav Datsyuk

Nick Lidstrom

Chris Osgood

Tom Holmstrom

Val Filppula

Jiri Hudler

Dan Cleary

Chris Chelios

Brian Rafalski

Chris Draper

Aaron Downey

Brett Lebda

Dom Hasek

Johan Franzen

Nik Kronvall

Mike Samuelson

Kirk Maltby

Tom Kopecky

Andreas Lilja

Dallas Drake

Matt Ellis

Derek Meech

Mark Hartigan

[OsGOD 3]

All favorites minus, in no particular order mind you:

Sammy

Hasek

and i am spent.. the rest of the guys make the grade i guess