95 replies to this topic

[Hockey God]

Name the top five fighters of all time mine are:
5) Bob "Battleship" Kelly
4) Joe Koucer
3) Dave Schultz
2) Tie Domi
1) Bob Probert

Honorable Mention:
Wendell Clark
John Wensik

Edited by Hockey God, 22 July 2010 - 04:39 PM.

[Carman]

Lilja

[titanium2]

Who are the top five fighters in the game today?

EDIT: Didn't like the way I worded the question in the first place.

Edited by titanium2, 16 April 2010 - 12:32 AM.

[Icemann778]

dont know exactly because its a game and anything can happen

[therock48880]

Name the top five fighters of all time mine are:
5) Bob "Battleship" Kelly
4) John Wensink
3) Dave Schultz
2) Tie Domi
1) Bob Probert

I can't include Domi in my list.

1. Probert
2. Kocur
3. Schultz
4. McSorley
5. Semenko

Numbers 2-5 are in no particular order.

[cjm502]

I have always said Kocur is the toughest sob to ever lace up skates, and im sticking with that.

[hockeysattva]

Since, you said fighter and enforcer, and since I'm not really in the mood for deciding where the Tony Twists of hockey belong, and since I want a list of Wings...
My five favorite fighters.

I've always loved watching Shanny fight. He had some real slug fests with Foote.
Darren McCarty he could play hockey, and throw down as needed nuff said.
[Honorable Mention: Chris Chelios, remember when he fought Luc... I distinctly remember his boy saying, "mom why is that man hitting daddy?"]
Probert and Kocur are gimmies, but they were really more on the enforcer end.

Fischer, he didn't fight much, but I'll also never forget the pounding he gave Hartnell after he healed. I would not what to be anywhere close to the receiving end of that. Plus he was just so young, he really had the passion.
Martin Lapoint, he had more upper body strength than any other Wing at that time, and he got into some great match-ups with guys who didn't realize it.
Mike Vernon, probably the chippiest netminder I'll give credit to

[F.Michael]

From what I've seen:

1) Probert
2) Kocur
3) Clark
4) McSorley
5) Domi

[Finnish Wing]

Rypien and Kane.

[F.Michael]

Rypien and Kane.

Kane puts another beatdown on a cabbie




I know you meant Evander

[Finnish Wing]

Kane puts another beatdown on a cabbie




I know you meant Evander

You never know...

[GMRwings1983]

1. Behn Wilson
2. Bob Probert
3. Dave Brown
4. Joey Kocur
5. Donald Brashear


Don't know how the OP can rank Wensink and Schultz ahead of guys like Wilson and Brown.

I think Probert is the best enforcer ever, but Behn Wilson has to be the best hockey fighter ever. Guy fought around 100 NHL fights and only lost around 5 or so times. None were bad losses either. He was the perfect fighter who had no weaknesses. Was a pretty good player as well on the blue line, scoring 360 points in 600 games or so, before injuries and laziness ended his career.

Also, I want to give a shout out to guys like Gillies, Nystrom and Playfair, who could easily be in anyone's top 5.

Edited by GMRwings1983, 16 April 2010 - 10:23 AM.

[NBCnothingbutcrosby]

1. Lilja
2. Lilja
3. Lilja
4. Lilja
5. Lilja

he'll hurt your fist with his head.

[Lidstromboli]

franzen
samuelsson

[DatsyukianDeke13]

Alexander Semin and here's proof

[micah]

In no order:

Bob Probert
Dave Brown
Dave Semenko
Joe Kocur
Behn Wilson

Laraque and Brashear could both be fit in there too.

Most skilled dominant fighter is Probert. Scariest fighter (as in the last guy I'd want mad at me) is dave Brown. Most entertaining is PJ Stock or Chris Murray. My most underrated is probably Sand McCarthy.

[newfy]

In the league right now I'm going with

Boogard

Colton Orr

Godard

Carkner

and Mcgratton

Might toss Ivanans in there but I wouldn't want him on my team. Laraque seems like hes done for now so I didnt count him either.

[Bring Back The Bruise Bros]

In no order:

Bob Probert
Dave Brown
Dave Semenko
Joe Kocur
Behn Wilson

Laraque and Brashear could both be fit in there too.

Most skilled dominant fighter is Probert. Scariest fighter (as in the last guy I'd want mad at me) is dave Brown. Most entertaining is PJ Stock or Chris Murray. My most underrated is probably Sand McCarthy.

Well Current ones i got:
Colton Orr
Brian McGrattan
Matt Carkner
Zenon Konopka
Cam Janssen

[newfy]

Well Current ones i got:
Colton Orr
Brian McGrattan
Matt Carkner
Zenon Konopka
Cam Janssen

Konopka isnt a top heavy. He's a light heavy that just fights alot. Youre not gonna see him against a guy like Orr. Janssen is crazy as hell but I dunno if he's a top notch fighter and deserves on the list over someone like Boogard.

[Bring Back The Bruise Bros]

Konopka isnt a top heavy. He's a light heavy that just fights alot. Youre not gonna see him against a guy like Orr. Janssen is crazy as hell but I dunno if he's a top notch fighter and deserves on the list over someone like Boogard.

I wasn't exactly sure if we were talking about pure heavyweights or not.In that case,Boogaard over Konopka.