Yeah, I'd prefer to see...
Namestnikov - Rasmussen - Svechnikov
Helm - Glendening - Gagner
It would be nice if it were always up to the player, but it's really not. We see younger players outperform older players all the time, and they still ride pine. We'll likely see a lot of Staal because of his "veteran presence" and "experience"...
Cholowski should be in the lineup most nights, if for no other reason than his ability to quarterback a power-play. The only other defenseman on the roster that can even do a half decent job on the PP, is Hronek. Cholowski obviously isn't anywhere near Hronek, but he is our next best option.